CashfulnessCashfulness
Download Cashfulness
Method

Revaluing your investments without anxiety: mark-to-market explained simply

30 October 202613 min

There's one figure in your wealth that changes even while you sleep.

It isn't the money in your account. That sits still.

It's your investments: the ETFs, the shares, the funds, the long-dated government bonds. Their value moves every day the markets are open, up or down, without asking your permission.

And that raises an awkward question.

If the value keeps changing, which number do I count in my wealth? The one from the day I bought them? Today's? Last night's close?

The answer to that question has a technical name, mark-to-market, and an enormous practical consequence for the calm with which you look at your money.

Because there's one way of handling that figure that generates anxiety. And there's another that generates a background fact, and nothing more.

What mark-to-market is

Let's start with the phrase, which is scarier than it deserves to be.

Mark-to-market means, quite literally, marking something to the market. And the sense of it is simple: valuing an investment at the market price on a given date, not at the price you paid when you bought it.

Let's take an example.

Three years ago Paolo bought an equity ETF, putting 10,000 euros into it.

Today his broker's statement says that the same ETF, at month-end market prices, is worth 12,300 euros.

Question: how much is that investment worth inside Paolo's wealth?

The most honest answer is 12,300 euros, as of the statement date. It's a documented estimate, with a source and a date. It isn't the exact value: how much he'd take home he would only find out by selling, at that day's price, minus fees and taxes. But it's far closer to reality than the purchase price: the 10,000 euros of three years ago are only a memory.

Marking to market means exactly this: take the most recent market value, with its source and its date, and use that.

The purchase price is good for one thing only: measuring how far up or down you are. In this case Paolo is up 2,300 euros. But the number that enters his wealth is the updated value, not the historical one.

Why the purchase price lies to you

Holding investments at their purchase price is convenient. It's a number you know, it's written on the receipt, it never changes.

But it's a number that tells you a lie.

Back to Paolo. If that ETF stays parked in his wealth at 10,000 euros, the price he paid, his coordinate is off by 2,300 euros on the low side. Paolo is more solid than he believes, and doesn't know it.

It works the other way round too, and that's the case that hurts.

Imagine the same ETF, instead of rising, has fallen. Bought at 10,000 euros, today it's worth 8,500.

If Paolo keeps counting it at 10,000, he's walking around with a coordinate inflated by 1,500 euros. He believes he has wealth he doesn't have. And on that false figure he might well take a decision: a purchase, a commitment, an "I can afford this".

That's the point. The purchase price isn't a neutral fact: it's an anchor that holds you still in the past while reality has already moved on.

Net worth, the coordinate of your position fix, everything you own minus everything you owe, only makes sense if every piece is valued at its most recent value.

An ETF at the price of three years ago inside today's wealth is like marking yesterday's position on the chart. It looks like a precise little cross. In fact it's no longer where you are.

Once a month, not once an hour

And now we come to the part that, to my mind, matters most of all. Not the what, but the when.

Because there's an obvious objection to all of this. If the value to use is the market one, and the market changes every second, then shouldn't I be updating my wealth constantly? Looking at it ten times a day?

No. On the contrary: that's exactly what not to do.

Watching the value of your investments every day, worse every hour, doesn't give you more information. It gives you more anxiety.

We all know that film. You open the broker app in the morning, you're green, you set off happy. You open it again at lunch, you're red, your stomach tightens. You open it in the evening, you're green again, but meanwhile you've burned through three doses of adrenaline over a movement that, on a horizon of years, means nothing.

Short-term noise, today's swing or this week's, isn't a signal. It's noise, precisely. And reacting to noise is the surest way to make bad decisions: selling out of fear when it falls, buying out of euphoria when it rises.

Revaluation exists to fix an up-to-date value, with a source and a date. Not to give you a reason to watch the markets all the time.

That's why the right rhythm is periodic and slow.

Once a month works perfectly well for most people. For someone with few investments and not very volatile ones, once a quarter is fine too.

I do it at month end, on my own wealth.

Once a month you take the value of your investments from the statement, you record it, your coordinate updates. Then you close, and for the next thirty days you don't need to open anything.

Thirty days of silence. That's the difference between having investments and guarding them.

Where this gesture lives in Cashfulness

Cashfulness is built for this rhythm, not for obsessive monitoring.

Much of what you do in the app is daily and light: you record a movement, and your coordinate updates by itself. But some things only make sense on a slower cadence: month end, quarter end, calmly, at a computer. Revaluing investments is one of them.

Among the app's tools there's an entry dedicated to exactly this, Investment Update, what the jargon calls mark-to-market, and an Asset Revaluation entry for possessions whose value changes over time.

How it works is simple, and not in the least automatic in the scary sense. You're the one who enters the updated value by hand: you open the tool, pick the investment, the app shows you the value it holds in your accounts, and you write the one from your broker's statement, with its date. There's no feed fishing out quotes on your behalf, no chart pulsing in real time. There's a number, you update it, when you decide to.

At that point the app computes the difference against the previous value and tells you whether it's an unrealized gain or an unrealized loss: a profit or a loss in value accrued on paper, until you sell. It exists as a number, but becomes money only on the day you close the position.

Then it prepares the entry, because the Cashfulness engine runs on double-entry: every fact is written on at least two accounts, and debits match credits. On one side the investment going up or down, on the other an account of Gains (an income) or Losses (an expense). You choose the counterpart: look at the transaction summary, check the two lines, and confirm. Only then does the entry go into your books.

Your current account, through all of this, doesn't move. Your wealth goes up or down; your cash stays still.

There's a product choice that should be stated plainly. In Cashfulness the unrealized gain goes through the income statement: it's income for the month, next to your salary, and the unrealized loss is an expense. That isn't a universal law: other systems, and some rules for companies, take certain changes in value straight to equity, without touching profit. Net worth ends up at the same number; only the route differs. With this choice, your income statement shows side by side how much came from work and how much from the market.

There's a second honest detail to add, because it affects anyone investing outside the euro.

A security bought in dollars, or in another currency, has two things moving together: the price of the security and the exchange rate. Both change its value in your main currency.

In Cashfulness multi-currency follows the account. If an account is in a currency other than your main one, you record movements there in its own currency, with no manual conversions. To translate it into your currency the app uses the European Central Bank's reference rates, published on working days, each with its date. A reference rate is a piece of information, not the price you buy at: your bank applies an effective rate that includes its spread.

And here is the second product choice. When only the exchange rate moves, the account in its own currency hasn't changed, so nothing is recorded: the exchange difference goes into your net worth, but not into the income statement. That's why, if you compare how much your net worth has grown with the profit for the period, the two numbers may not match: part of the difference is the exchange rate. A company would usually record it instead as a foreign exchange gain or loss.

You don't chase exchange rates. You keep the account in its own currency, and the overall picture of your wealth stays aligned in the currency you actually think in.

The principle, in any case, stays the same: a photograph of the value, with source and date, taken calmly once a month.

Investments and things that wear out: two opposite movements

There's a useful symmetry to see here.

Investments, broadly speaking, are meant to grow over time: not always, not steadily, but that's their function. They fall under what we call Asset+: the possessions that pay you, with a flow or with growth in value.

Plenty of other possessions do the opposite. The car, the phone, the furniture, the appliances lose value as you use them. They aren't investments: they're things you need which, meanwhile, wear out.

The mark-to-market principle applies to both, but in two directions.

You revalue the ETF because it has probably risen (or fallen) against the purchase price.

You write down the car because it's certainly worth less than when you bought it. A car paid 30,000 euros three years ago is worth maybe 18,000 today, going by second-hand listings. Those 18,000 euros are the number that belongs in your wealth, not the 30,000 on the invoice.

The decline in value of something that wears out has a technical name of its own: depreciation. It's the orderly way of recording a durable good's loss of value over time, instead of pretending it's forever worth what it was new. A company usually follows a plan decided in advance; at home it's an estimate, which you make yourself, with second-hand listings and a date.

Cashfulness has a dedicated tool for this too.

The underlying idea is a single one, and it holds both directions together: nothing in your wealth stays parked at yesterday's price. What grows, you follow as it grows; what wears out, you follow as it wears. In both cases the number you see is up to date, and you know where it comes from.

An example, to see the difference

Let's put it as two people, identical wealth on paper, two different habits.

Giulia never revalues. In her mental ledger, her investments are still worth what she paid for them: 40,000 euros paid in over the years. She counts her car at 28,000 euros, the dealership price. Giulia "believes" she has a certain wealth, but it's an old estimate, frozen on the day of each purchase.

Andrea revalues once a month, ten minutes at month end. His 40,000 euros paid in are worth 46,000 at the statement's prices: the markets have been kind. His car, estimated from second-hand listings, is worth 17,000, not 28,000.

Look at what happens. Andrea discovers two things in the same gesture: that his investments are worth 6,000 euros more than he thought, and that his car is worth 11,000 less.

The two corrections very nearly cancel out. But the point isn't the final balance.

The point is that Andrea's coordinate is documented, with sources and dates, while Giulia's is a guess dressed up as a certainty.

And when one of the two has to take an important decision (moving house, facing a big expense, working out whether they can cut back on work) Andrea starts from a fact. Giulia starts from a feeling.

This, incidentally, touches the fourth coordinate of the position fix: the gap between the wealth you believe you have and the wealth you actually have, the coordinate the app doesn't calculate for you. Revaluing regularly is one of the gestures that keeps it close to zero.

The serene rhythm, and why it matters

I want to close on this, because it's what really separates the calm way from the anxious way.

Revaluation isn't monitoring. It's maintenance.

Monitoring means hovering over something because you're afraid it will go wrong. It's a gesture driven by fear, and by its nature it never ends: the more you look, the more you want to look.

Doing maintenance means giving a precise, rare, quiet moment to keeping a tool in order. You do it, it's done, you forget about it until next time.

Watching your portfolio every day is monitoring. Revaluing at month end is maintenance.

The same goes for the rest of the monthly ritual: when you reconcile your accounts against the real statements and when you revalue your investments, you're doing the same thing in the same spirit. Once a month, calmly, you give your numbers a coat of truth. Then you close.

Thirty days of silence until the next time. Not because you're ignoring your money, but because you've put it in such good order that it doesn't need you every day.

And one note, because someone will be expecting it: through all of this Cashfulness never tells you what to do with your investments. It doesn't tell you to buy, to sell, to hold. It doesn't sell financial products and has no interest in the number you see.

It gives you the up-to-date value, photographed calmly once a month, with its source and its date. What to do with it is your choice, and you make it informed, not frightened.

Because in the end money is a tool for buying time and freedom. And the time you don't spend staring at a chart that wobbles is exactly one of the pieces of freedom this method gives you back.

Vittorio